A disciplined contribution calculator for comparing what is left from completed delivery, collection and eat-in orders after actual direct costs and refunds.
New for 2026 practical guide
At a glance
Measure this
Realised Variable Contribution per Fulfilled Order: Channel-specific variable contribution from fulfilled orders divided by completed or fulfilled orders, reported with total contribution and refund rate.The 2026 Café Margin Reset
Compare what the café actually keeps to cover fixed costs
A delivery ticket can increase sales while leaving a different amount to cover rent, management, utilities and owner return than a similar collection or eat-in sale. A customer-facing menu price alone cannot answer the question. The comparison needs the VAT treatment recorded by the POS, the actual platform or payment fee, ingredients, packaging, incremental labour, own-delivery cost where relevant, discounts, refunds and cancellation adjustments.
This guide asks one limited question: after sales VAT and direct variable costs, what is left from realised completed orders in each channel to contribute towards fixed costs and profit? It is a management control, not a tax return, a statutory record or a guarantee of profitability.
1. Build the settings tab before entering a sale
Choose one accounting basis and keep it consistent. A non-VAT-registered café normally records gross cash values. A VAT-registered café using normal or cash accounting should retain gross and VAT fields, while using the appropriate net sales and recoverable-cost basis for the management comparison. A Flat Rate Scheme user should keep a separate reconciliation: HMRC says input VAT on purchases normally cannot be reclaimed under that scheme, subject to a limited capital-asset exception. 1
The standard VAT rate is 20%. Where an item is correctly standard-rated and the price includes VAT, the VAT fraction is gross × 20/120 and net is gross ÷ 1.20. Do not use that shortcut for a mixed-rate basket. HMRC says that food or drink consumed on the supplier’s premises is standard-rated; cold takeaway food may have a different treatment, while hot takeaway food and some beverages require their own analysis. Use product tax codes and evidence, not channel labels. 2
| Input field | Delivery | Collection | Eat-in | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Order ID, date, channel and outcome | Yes | Yes | Yes | Retain non-completed tickets and mark the outcome. |
| Gross café food/drink amount | Yes | Yes | Yes | Exclude third-party charges unless the contract makes them the café’s sale. |
| Café-funded discount and refund | Yes | Yes | Yes | Link each to the original ticket and statement or credit note. |
| Output VAT | Yes | Yes | Yes | Use POS/product tax data rather than one assumed rate. |
| Platform, payment and delivery fee | Usually | Sometimes | Payment fee | Keep net fee, fee VAT and cash debit separately. |
| Food, packaging and incremental labour | Yes | Yes | Yes | Cost only what the order genuinely causes. |
2. Enter actual fees, not a market shorthand
Use the signed agreement and invoice for realised results. Published figures can only be scenario inputs. Uber’s UK merchant page lists 30% Uber Delivery, 33% for Uber One members, and 13% for Self-Delivery and Pick-up, all excluding VAT; its terms state the marketplace fee is calculated on the item retail price including VAT. 3 A £20 standard-rated food sale contains £3.33 output VAT. A £6 commission is 30% of gross £20, but 36% of £16.67 net food sale before ingredients, packaging or labour. That is arithmetic from a stated fee basis, not a typical-margin claim.
Deliveroo’s public terms say the applicable service fee is a percentage of VAT-inclusive GMV plus VAT, but do not give every café a universal rate. Enter the rate in the café’s agreement and the fee on the actual invoice. Its cancellation policy should be checked in the same way: a café-fault cancellation can mean no payment while a fee and VAT are still charged. 4
Capture every material line separately: commission, delivery or self-delivery fee, fee VAT, payment processing, adverts, promotions, tablet/integration costs, fixed charges, customer refunds, credits, chargebacks and prior-period corrections. A platform payout is a cash settlement, not automatically the café’s sales revenue or the contribution from that week’s completed orders.
3. Apply one contribution formula to every channel
Net café food sales
= (gross café food-and-drink receipts - café-funded discounts - sales refunds/credits)
- output VAT on that net supply
Variable contribution
= net café food sales
- platform commission and other platform charges
- direct payment fee
- recipe food-and-drink cost
- packaging/disposables
- incremental labour
- own-delivery cost
- remake, waste, refund-administration and other direct costs
+ credits the café actually retains
For a normally VAT-registered café with valid invoices and recoverable input tax, show expense inputs net of recoverable VAT. Mark each line “yes/no/confirm” rather than assuming all VAT is recoverable. Keep the fee VAT cash amount in a separate reconciliation column. HMRC requires appropriate records and valid VAT invoices for input-tax recovery. 5
Do not allocate the whole rota to delivery or collection. Sample at least 20 orders per meaningful channel and daypart, recording make, pack, handover and refund-administration minutes. Convert the observed incremental minutes using the café’s documented fully loaded hourly employment cost. Base roster labour, rent and ordinary equipment costs should sit outside an order-level variable calculation unless the decision really changes them.
Use a current item card for each product or bundle. Cost ingredients from the latest invoice and usable yield, then add every cup, lid, carrier, bag, tamper seal, container, cutlery and napkin actually used. A collection order may still need packaging, and an eat-in order may still use variable consumables.
4. Reconcile cash without confusing it with contribution
Expected platform cash payout
= platform-collected café receipts
- commission and other charges including fee VAT
- statement adjustments and refunds
+/- prior-period corrections
Tie that calculation to the bank credit, then reconcile the sales component to the order export and VAT account. Keep the POS Z-read or daily gross takings report, platform order report, settlement statement, fee invoice, refund log, bank receipt and cash-up record for the same period. HMRC guidance identifies records such as cash books, bank statements, purchase and sales records, invoices and daily takings as VAT business records. 5
Apply extra caution if the café uses the VAT Cash Accounting Scheme. It accounts for output tax when payment is received and input tax when the supplier is paid, but that does not mean the weekly platform payout date is automatically the right VAT date. Platform contracts can say the platform collected payment on the café’s behalf. Ask the accountant to review the actual terms and document the treatment. 6
5. Review for 21 days, changing one variable at a time
Create a weekly dashboard by channel: fulfilled orders, gross café receipts, refunds, net food sales, platform/payment fees, recipe cost, packaging, incremental labour, variable contribution, contribution rate and refund rate. Reconcile the dashboard before changing a price, menu range, promotion, packaging specification or channel route.
Test one action at a time, such as a delivery-only bundle or a collection prompt. Preserve a comparable before-and-after period and record exceptional weather, closures, stock-outs, large refunds and price changes. A higher percentage with lower contribution pounds can still mean less money available for fixed costs. For direct ordering, keep customer prices and unavoidable charges clear and timely; the CMA’s price-transparency guidance says mandatory fees, taxes and delivery charges should normally be included in the total where they can reasonably be calculated. 7
Primary KPI: Realised Variable Contribution per Fulfilled Order (RVC/FO).
RVC/FO (£) = total variable contribution of fulfilled orders in a channel
÷ number of fulfilled orders in that channel
Variable contribution rate (%) = total variable contribution
÷ total net café food sales × 100
Each Monday, export the prior week’s POS report by VAT code/channel, platform order and settlement reports, payment charges, refunds and time-sample sheet. Count a fulfilled order only when the café prepared and handed over or supplied it. Keep cancelled/refunded tickets in the numerator at their actual cost and sales effect, but not in the fulfilled-order denominator. Report refunds separately so the KPI cannot conceal them.
Printable worksheet
2026 CAFÉ MARGIN RESET — WEEKLY CHANNEL CONTRIBUTION WORKSHEET
Week ending: __________ Prepared by: __________ VAT/accounting mode: ______________
BEFORE INPUT
[ ] Channel labels confirmed [ ] Product VAT codes checked [ ] Latest recipe/pack costs loaded
[ ] Fully loaded hourly cost and incremental minutes documented
[ ] Platform agreement, order export, settlement and fee VAT invoice saved
CHANNEL: __________________ Fulfilled orders: ______
Gross café food/drink receipts £________
Less café-funded discounts £________
Less sales refunds/credits £________
Less output VAT from POS/tax report £________
Net café food sales £________
Platform/POS fees excluding recoverable VAT £________
Fee VAT (cash reconciliation only) £________
Recipe food/drink cost £________
Packaging/disposables £________
Incremental labour: ______ minutes x £______/hour £________
Own-driver/courier cost £________
Remake, waste, refund administration/other direct cost £________
VARIABLE CONTRIBUTION £________
RVC/FO £________
Contribution rate ________%
CASH AND VAT CHECK
[ ] Every refund/cancellation has an order ID and statement/credit-note line.
[ ] Expected payout reconciles to bank credit. Difference: £________ Explained? [ ]
[ ] POS daily gross takings reconcile by VAT code.
[ ] Accountant/VAT-adviser question to resolve: ______________________________________
21-DAY REVIEW
One controlled action: __________________ Owner: __________ Start: ______ Review: ______
No revenue, margin, labour-saving or compliance result is promised. [ ]
Caveats and source note
This calculator is not tax, accounting, legal, employment, platform-contract or consumer-price advice. It does not decide VAT liability, agency/principal status, fee entitlement, input-tax recovery or legal compliance. Rates, fee bases, refunds, promotions and settlement timing may be bespoke. A positive contribution is not proof of full profitability after fixed costs; a negative result does not automatically mean a channel should close. Do not claim that it guarantees margin, cash flow, revenue, staffing savings or compliance.
Sources reviewed 18 September 2026. The URLs below are the source URLs used in this guide.
References
Checked for this guide
Sources and review date
Primary sources set the compliance and platform guidance. Trade publications are marked as directional signals, not forecasts or guarantees.
- PrimaryHM Revenue & Customs / GOV.UK, Catering, takeaway food (VAT Notice 709/1)
- PrimaryHM Revenue & Customs / GOV.UK, Record keeping (VAT Notice 700/21)
- PrimaryUber Eats for Merchants, Flexible pricing and fees to help you reach your goals
- PrimaryDeliveroo, Deliveroo Partners Terms and Conditions
- PrimaryCompetition and Markets Authority / GOV.UK, Providing clear and accurate information about prices: summary
